About Us

Over 142 years of experience

The Home Mutual Insurance Company was formed by a group of citizens in 1876 in the city of Tell City, Indiana. Since that time we have grown and currently employ 9 people and have 2 offices located in south-western Indiana.

We are a mutual company licensed to do business in the state of Indiana with wholly owned insurance agency that provide all lines of insurance coverage including Commercial, Home, Auto, Farm, Life, Health, Annuities and Bonds in both Indiana and Kentucky.

We have an In House Claims Department which allows us to pay many of your claims right from our office.

The Right Products for Your Individual or Your Business Needs are available for you at Home Mutual Insurance Co & Agency and German Mutual Insurance Agency. We represent many different insurance companies through our independent agency which allows us to find the right coverage for all of our client’s unique needs.

We are eager to serve you, we will sit down with you, discuss your operation, make an independent survey of your insurance needs and evaluate your current insurance program.

Excellent Service at a Competitive Price is Our Goal for you. Our dedicated staff is always available to assist you with any questions you might have. You may directly contact either of our offices for your needs, or simply email the quote sheet on this website. Either way, we will strive to make your experience with us a positive one.